Assessing Speaking Skills in Core French Grade 12 (Challenge Discussion Rubric)
The student is expected to sustain a 5-8 minute discussion in
the target language with two other
partners
Information about the discussion:
You will participate in a discussion (5 to 8 minutes) with two partners who will
be assigned to you on the day of the examination. Your topic will be given to
you on a card. You will have a minute to clarify the task, then you and your
partners will have approximately 8 minutes to prepare.
During the preparation time, you should think or talk about your ideas on the
topic. Partners may wish to take differing points of view in order to better
sustain the discussion. The examiner will mark your discussion using the attached
scale.
This activity gives you the opportunity to demonstrate your achievement of the
following outcomes:
• exchange ideas and thoughts about areas of personal interest;
• give reasons and information to support points of view on various issues.
During the examination you will be expected to:
• engage in a discussion;
• use your skills and knowledge to develop the discussion by asking each
other questions; offering your opinions, reasons, ideas, arguments; interacting
with and responding to others’ ideas and cues; supporting your partner(s);
Exceeds Expectations |
Fully meets expectations |
Meets expectations |
Minimally meets expectations |
Does not yet meet expectations |
| • ideas clearly & effectively stated | • position/opinion is clear | • understandable point of view | • point of view may be vague; message understandable with effort | • parts can be understood by teacher |
| • logical reasons, examples, details | • details and reasoning provided | • some detail, support | • few details, support | • little, no detail |
| • responds to others with relevant questions, ideas • sustains interaction |
• attempts to respond to others' ideas • sustains interaction; may be hesitant |
• may not respond to others' ideas • may be hesitant; frequent short pauses |
• no evidence of recognizing or responding to others' views • long frequent breaks |
• little/no communication • frequent extended pauses or breaks |
| • expression, intonation help make meaning clear • attempts complex language to make meaning precise |
• appropriate expression, intonation • appropriate structures, language |
• some appropriate expression, intonation • basic structures, language |
• some expression, intonation may support meaning • repetitive; basic structures; language |
• repetitive; simple language • may include English words and phrases |
| • minor errors do not interfere with effectiveness | • errors do not interfere with effectiveness | • errors may weaken communication | • frequent errors may disrupt communication | • serious, frequent errors may prevent communication |
0: Does not contribute and/or message may be extremely brief, unintelligible, inappropriate, or include frequent use of English. |
||||
Assessing Speaking Skills in Core French Grade 11 (Challenge Conversation Rubric)
The student is expected to sustain a 3 to 5 minute conversation in the target
language with a partner
Information about the conversation:
You will be asked to converse for 3 to 5 minutes with a partner who will be assigned
to you on the day of the examination. You and your partner will receive a card
that describes a common life situation. You will have a minute to clarify the
task if necessary; then you and your partner will have 6 to 8 minutes to prepare.
During the preparation time, you should work together to create a framework for
your conversation and decide on your ideas. The examiner will mark your conversation
using the attached scale.
This activity gives you the opportunity to demonstrate your achievement of the
following outcomes:
• express plans, goals and intentions in the short and long term;
• interact effectively and with some spontaneity, in the target language,
in familiar situations drawn from real life.
During the examination you will be expected to:
• participate spontaneously in a simulated conversation;
• use your skills and knowledge to develop the conversation;
• interact, responding to cues and supporting your partner.
Your conversation does not have to be dramatic; you can speak normally as you
would in any conversation.
Exceeds Expectations
|
Fully meets expectations |
Meets expectations
|
Minimally meets expectations
|
Does not yet meet expectations
|
| • very clear message | • clear message | • understandable message | • basic message understandable with effort | • parts can be understood by teacher |
| • effective details (logical reasons, examples) | • some relevant details (reasons, examples) | • some detail, support | • few details, support | • little, no detail |
| • sustains interaction • easily supports or rescues others |
• sustains interaction; may be hesitant • may support others |
• may not respond to others' ideas • may be hesitant; frequent short pauses |
• no evidence of responding to others • long frequent breaks |
• may speak infrequently; briefly; little/no communication • frequent extended pauses or breaks |
| • expression, intonation help make meaning clear • attempts complex language to make meaning precise |
• appropriate expression, intonation • appropriate structures, language |
• some appropriate expression, intonation • basic structures, language |
• some expression, intonation may support meaning • repetitive; basic structures; language |
• repetitive; simple language • may include English words and phrases |
| • minor errors do not interfere with effectiveness | • errors do not interfere with effectiveness | • errors may weaken communication | • frequent errors may disrupt communication | • serious, frequent errors may prevent communication |
0: Does not contribute and/or message may be extremely brief, unintelligible, inappropriate, or include frequent use of English. |
||||